The Columbus Jewish Historical Society

By Austin Reid

Dedicated to the members of Congregation Anshe Emeth who have kept the light of Judaism
burning in the Upper Miami Valley for over 150 years. Austin Reid, August, 2021.

Introduction: The First Jewish Families in the Upper Miami Valley

Situated between two homes along Caldwell Street in Piqua is Congregation Anshe
Emeth, the center of Ohio’s fourth-oldest organized Jewish community. While the current tan
two-story brick building housing Anshe Emeth dates to 1922, the group was organized over sixty
years prior on March 7, 1858.^[1] For over 150 years, Jews have been represented among the
religious communities of the Upper Miami Valley. The story of Jewish life in the area, however,
does not begin with the creation of Anshe Emeth. Rather, Jews are known to have lived in Piqua
and Troy since the 1840s and it is likely that Jews were among the itinerant traders passing
through the area during the 1830s. Jews and other ethnic and religious groups came to Miami
County in increased numbers after the Miami & Erie Canal was extended north of Dayton in
1837. This canal connected Miami County to Cincinnati, Ohio’s largest city during the 1800s,
and enabled business people from the city and others living along the Ohio River to quickly
reach Miami and surrounding counties. Cincinnati at the time was also home to Ohio’s largest
Jewish community and its oldest Jewish institutions. Most, if not all, of Miami County’s earliest
Jewish residents spent time in Cincinnati before moving north.

Emma and Moses Friedlich are the first Jewish family known to have lived in Piqua. The
couple arrived in town in 1849 when Piqua’s population was around 3,200. Emma and Moses
were, like many American Jews at the time, immigrants from Bavaria; they were married in 1841
after their arrival in the United States.^[2] After settling in Piqua, Moses opened a clothing store on
Main Street, which he managed until his retirement in 1891. He also was involved in the creation
of Citizens National Bank in 1865 and served as a director and vice president of the bank from
1870 until his death in 1892.^[3] Emma and Moses raised at least three children, Caroline, Jacob,
and Tillie. The husband and wife were not the first members of the Friedlich family to reside in
Piqua. In 1846 Moses’ brother, Aaron arrived in town and found work as a tailor. Around 1850
Aaron married Theresa and the couple had ten children, five sons, and five daughters. These
children would eventually move to various places, including Bowling Green, Cleveland, Iowa,
Rochester, and Wapakoneta. Aaron and Theresa, however, lived in Piqua for the remainder of
their lives and they made several contributions to their adopted city. Most notably, Aaron served
for a number of years as a member of the local Board of Education and was president of Piqua’s
Social Club.^[4] Emma, Moses, Aaron and Theresa are all commemorated on the stained glass
windows found in Anshe Emeth today.

Eight miles south of Piqua in Troy, a Jewish presence
was also growing by the 1840s. Levi and Nancy Barnett
along with Jenny and Joseph Wertheimer are the first
Jews known to have lived in town. Both couples arrived
in the 1840s and both Levi and Joseph supported their
families by selling clothing. During the mid to late
1800s, the clothing business, which was rapidly growing
due to technological advances in sewing, represented a
major economic area for recent immigrants. Jews in
America, who were primarily born in Central Europe or
second-generation Americans, were particularly likely to become involved
in the clothing business because of anti-immigrant or anti-Jewish sentiment in other trades and a tradition in many families
of operating small businesses in Europe. Family connections also allowed many newer immigrants to enter the
clothing business. As an example, it was not uncommon for a brother to emigrate to the United
States and send money back to pay for the voyage of his other siblings after establishing a stable
business. These siblings would work for their brother upon arriving in America and sometimes
go on to create their own stores in new towns.

In Troy as in Piqua, Jews involved themselves in communal activities. Levi was a
member of the Independent Order of Odd Fellows, a fraternal organization, and one of the
Barnett children, Jacob, would become a member of the local Elks lodge.^[5] Organizations such as
the Elks and Odd Fellows filled an important need within 19th-century communities. In an era
before Social Security and other social welfare programs, communal societies such as these
served not only social purposes, but also as a type of insurance providing medical care and
disability benefits for members. Fraternal societies would also provide funds to cover at least
some of the burial costs for members and they helped to support any orphans left behind by the
deceased. Some Jews also affiliated themselves with religious and social institutions in larger
cities to maintain connections with the wider Jewish community. The oldest Jewish organization
in the Miami Valley, Temple Israel traces its origins to 1850 when twelve Jews gathered in
Dayton to form a Hebrew Society. This Society was dedicated to organizing religious services
and creating a set burial ground for Jews.^[6] The Society’s early members included individuals in
the Friedlich family. In 1852 Gelinde Friedlich was buried at the Rubicon Cemetery in Dayton,
which had been organized by Society members as the region’s first Jewish cemetery in 1851. At
the time of her death, Gelinde was just seven years old.^[7] Jews in Piqua, Greenville, Sidney, and
Troy also traveled to larger cities to maintain social ties with other Jews. The foremost Jewish
fraternal organization was known as B’nai B’rith and in 1864 a lodge was formed in Dayton.
Known as the Eschol Lodge, the organization is the ancestor of the B’nai B’rith Youth
Organization, which continues to exist in Dayton into the 21st century. Over the years, many
Jews from Darke, Miami and Shelby counties would affiliate themselves as members of the
lodge. Not until 1944 would a B’nai B’rith lodge be formed in the Upper Miami Valley.^[8]

During the 1850s, more Jews arrived in Piqua and Troy. These included Henry Flesh,
Herz Landauer, Abraham Lebensburger, Charles Lebolt and Esther Lebolt, David and Regina
Louis, Barbara Schwab, and Abraham and Fannie Wendel. It is also during this same decade that
the first Jewish residents of Greenville were recorded. These residents included Charles and Julia
Bachman, Henrietta and Simon Bachman, Moses Huhn, and Joseph Oppenheimer. Henry Flesh,
who was born in Ellingen, Bavaria, immigrated to the United States in 1852 at the age of 15 or
16. In 1856 he moved to Troy from Dayton and in 1858 he relocated to Piqua. Once in Piqua,
Henry found work with Aaron Friedlich selling clothing. He remained with Aaron until 1862
when he decided to go into business for himself. Henry’s business and civic interests expanded
and by the 1880s he was among Piqua’s most notable citizens. More on this will be written later.
Hertz Landauer and Abraham Wendel came to Piqua as peddlers. Hertz met Barbara Schwab
after settling in Piqua and the two married but did not have any children.^[9] Barbara may have
been related to Solomon Schwab, who is listed in The Israelite, a Jewish newspaper out of
Cincinnati, as a Piqua resident and the fiancé of Bertha Hessberg of Cincinnati in 1861. No other
records of Solomon’s time in Piqua were located. More information, however, exists regarding
Abraham Wendel.

Abraham was born in Prussia in 1821 and came to the United States in 1848. By 1852 he
made his way to Piqua where he met Fannie Friedlich, the sister of Aaron and Moses. The couple
wed shortly after and seven children were born from the union.^[10] In 1856 Abraham saved enough
money to put aside the peddler’s pack and open a jewelry store on Main Street. One son, Jacob
remained in Piqua as an adult to carry on the business. Another child of Abraham and Fannie
died in infancy and, Samuel, the youngest son died at the age of 22. All four of the Wendel
daughters moved out of Piqua after their marriages. Bertha and Sadie moved to Portland,
Oregon, while Helen and Rose married men living in Cincinnati. Helen moved to Greenville
with her husband, Abraham Simon by 1900. Abraham would become a notable cattle and wool
merchant in Darke County.^[11]Both Abraham and Fannie are commemorated on the stained glass
windows of Anshe Emeth.

Abraham Lebensburger, Charles Lebolt, and David Louis all owned businesses in Piqua
by 1860. Abraham was involved in the local clothing trade from 1858 until 1883, when he
moved to Chicago with his wife, Caroline. Abraham was also the brother-in-law of both Charles
and David. Charles married Esther Lebensburger in 1854, three years after his arrival in Piqua.
At the time, Esther lived in Dayton. Interestingly, Charles and Esther had grown up only a few
miles from each other in Bavaria and they reunited after immigrating to the United States.^[12]The
husband and wife were married for over 50 years and they had ten children. These children
would mostly move to either Springfield, Missouri or Springfield, Ohio. David married Regina
Lebensburger in the late 1850s and the couple had at least four children. In addition to sharing
family ties, both Charles and David were involved in the grocery business. The two men also
shared similar community activities as members of B’nai B’rith, United Ancient Order of Druids
and Odd Fellows.

Greenville’s earliest Jewish residents shared many traits with their coreligionists in Piqua
and Troy. The Bachmans, Moses Huhn, and Joseph Oppenheimer were all immigrants from
German-speaking regions of Europe and all spent at least some time in the clothing business
once in Greenville. It is of note that the presence of German-Jewish immigrants in the Upper
Miami Valley by the mid-19th century was part of a larger national pattern. Between the years
1820 and 1880, an estimated 150,000 Jews would arrive in the United States from predominantly
German-speaking regions of Europe. Jews, however, comprised but a small part of the
approximately three million German-speaking immigrants in total who came to the United States
during the same period.^[13] Most German-speaking lands would become part of the modern
German state when it was created in 1871. During the decades preceding this event, however,
much of Central Europe was beset by revolutions and other forms of political and economic
turmoil. In 1848, revolutions became especially widespread throughout Europe ushering in an
exceptionally large wave of immigration. Central European Jews, who were often subjected to
violence and discriminatory laws that limited their economic opportunities and ability to marry,
faced additional incentives to emigrate.

Some German-Jewish immigrants to the United States became wealthy. One such
immigrant was Simon Bachman. By the time of his death in 1907, Simon achieved success in
business through his clothing store on Broadway Street. For a number of years, Simon also
operated a saloon on East Main Street named the Lion Garden.^[14] This business took its name
from the Lion Brewery in Cincinnati. Simon’s life, however, had its sorrows. Of the 12 children
born to Simon and Henrietta, only four were living when Simon died.^[15] Henrietta Rosenbush
married Simon in 1854, and the couple remained together for over 50 years. At the time of
Henrietta’s death in 1912, she was one of Greenville’s oldest residents having reached the age of
82.^[16] The Greenville Democrat referred to Henrietta as a “pioneer lady” in her obituary and
remarked, “being exemplary Jews never interfered with the [Bachman] family mingling with all
other denominational people.^[17]” While intended as a laudatory statement, the paper’s comment
also reveals a certain bias that viewed many Jews as holding themselves at a distance from the
larger community due to their faith. This belief was not reflected in Greenville or the hundreds of
other cities and towns in which American Jews lived by the early 20th century.

Charles Bachman, who was likely a brother of Simon, founded the Bachman’s Boss
Clothing House on Broadway in 1859. For a time he also owned a store named the Elephant
Clothing Company. He and his wife, Julia had at least four children. Joseph Oppenheimer lived
in Greenville by 1852 and he operated the California Clothing Store on Broadway. In 1853 the
Oppenheimer store was renamed the People’s Clothing Store and it operated under this name
until at least 1859. It is also of note that Joseph, along with dozens of other locals, helped to
finance the construction of the Greenville Palestine turnpike in 1856.^[18] By 1866, Joseph sold his
clothing store to Moses Huhn. Moses lived in Greenville since 1858 and his first job in town was
working at F. & J. Waring’s dry goods store. Moses was also active in the community as treasurer
of the Volunteer Fire Company and as a member of the Masons and Odd Fellows.^[1] It does not
appear that Moses ever married. Following his death in 1897, Morris, a nephew of Moses, took
over the clothing business. The example of People’s Clothing Store demonstrates how some
Jewish-owned businesses were passed along to other Jews, who could be either relatives or
connections from the wider Jewish community, by older owners. Other businesses would follow
similar paths in later years.

A Place to Gather: The Establishment of Congregation Anshe Emeth

By the late 1850s, Piqua’s approximately eight Jewish families were sufficiently
organized to establish a formal society for religious study and worship. This organization, Anshe
Emeth, was created on March 7, 1858, and its name
translates to People of Truth.^[20] From its earliest years,
Anshe Emeth also drew Jews from surrounding areas
such as Greenville and Troy to its services, which were
initially conducted once a month and on certain
religious holidays at the home of Moses Friedlich.^[21]
Within a year the members of Anshe Emeth relocated
to a rented hall found at 200 North Main where the congregation
remained until 1875. The first officers of the congregation were,
Moses Friedlich, President, Aaron Friedlich,Treasurer, and Moritz Friedman, Secretary.^[22] Moritz,
who does not appear to have lived in Piqua for long, operated a clothing business out of the
Masonic Building alongside a man named August Frickman. While modest in size, Anshe Emeth did
not escape notice from larger Jewish communities in Ohio. Rather, even in its infancy Anshe
Emeth was cited by The Israelite as setting an example of dedication and piety for Jews in other
small towns to emulate.^[23] In 1859Abraham Wendel replaced Aaron Friedlich as treasurer.
Abraham, who was a skilled scholar of Hebrew, also served as a lay leader for the congregation until
his death in 1894.^[24]

Ordained rabbis occasionally visited Anshe Emeth to speak or lead major holiday
services. On July 4, 1860, Rabbi Isaac Mayer Wise of Cincinnati, who was the foremost
American rabbi of the time, visited the congregation to deliver a lecture. Reflecting on his visit to
Piqua a few days later Rabbi Wise wrote:

Our brethren [in Piqua] are few in number, about seven families, still they united
themselves two years ago into a congregation, bought land for a burial ground, furnished
a room for a temporary synagogue, where they meet once a month for divine worship…
People in those county places live much happier and more content in their quiet places
then we do in our noisy cities with all our opulence, luxury, refinements, and studied
gratification of our passions.^[25]

The burial ground referenced by Rabbi Wise is Cedar Hill Cemetery, which is now located along
Scott Drive in Piqua. At the time of the cemetery’s establishment in 1858, however, the area was not built up. Cedar Hill is the final resting place, not only of many Jewish families from Piqua, but also individuals from nearby towns including Lima, which did not have its own Jewish cemetery until 1917.^[26] In September 1859, Abraham Levi became one of the first people to be buried at Cedar Hill Cemetery. It is possible that Abraham Leviwas a clothing merchant from Greenville since a businessman by this name was advertising in the local Darke County Democrat by 1857. No advertisements for Abraham are found, however,after 1858.

In addition to maintaining a rented hall and burial ground, the early members of Anshe
Emeth also organized to support various charitable causes both locally and internationally. In
1860 the congregation raised $50 to benefit Jews in Morocco who were suffering from
persecution.^[27] At the time, $50 would have the same purchasing power as approximately $1,600
in 2021. In 1866, Congregation Anshe Emeth sent $25 to benefit impoverished Jews living in
Palestine.^[28] These two collections demonstrate that, while Piqua was still a modest-sized town of
approximately 5,000 people, its Jewish residents saw themselves as connected with the wider
Jewish world and were familiar with events far beyond the Upper Miami Valley. This same
outlook was shared by non-Jews living in the area who were also connecting with far-flung
communities through new technologies such as the telegraph, which first came to Piqua in 1850.
Piqua’s first railroad line, which came through town in 1858, also spurred news and additional
population growth.^[29]

The April 12, 1861, attack on Fort Sumter in Charleston, South Carolina, profoundly
affected life in the Upper Miami Valley. Within a short time, many local men joined the Union
Army and other residents found additional ways to support the war effort. In October 1862, the
110th Regiment was organized at Camp Piqua. While it is not known if any Jews served in the
local regiment, two Jews who moved to Piqua in the years following the Civil War, Moses Flesh
and David Urbansky, are known to have served in the Union Army. Moses Flesh, who was the
brother of Henry Flesh, served in the 23rd Wisconsin Infantry Regiment. This regiment saw
action at Port Gibson, Champion Hill, the Siege of Vicksburg, and other places.^[30] Moses was
wounded during the war, and, after relocating to Piqua, he became active in the local Elks lodge
and Grand Army of the Republic post.^[31] He was also a member of Anshe Emeth and was one of
five people to sign the congregation’s revised articles of incorporation in 1924. Moses, who was
known by many as “Uncle Mose”, also played Santa Claus for many years at the Kaoop
Children’s Home during the Christmas season.^[32]

David Urbansky lived in Columbus, Ohio, at the time of the war’s outbreak, and, like
Moses, he was a recent immigrant from Central Europe.^[33] Six months after the attack on Fort
Sumter, David enlisted with the 48th Ohio Volunteer Infantry, which saw action at the Battle of
Shiloh, Siege of Corinth, Vicksburg, and several other locations. In recognition of his bravery at
the Battle of Shiloh, David was awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor. Thirteen months
later in Vicksburg David was again commended for his actions after he braved enemy fire to
rescue an officer who had been wounded.^[34] Only 17 other Ohioans received the Medal of Honor
during the war and only five other Jews in the Union Army were recognized in this way.^[35]
Following the war, David obtained his American citizenship and moved to Piqua with his new
wife, Rachel. The couple had 12 children and David ran a successful clothing store. At the time
of David’s death in 1897, he was buried at Cedar Hill Cemetery and his widow soon moved to
Cincinnati. Several of the Urbansky children also relocated to Cincinnati, and when Rachel died
in 1914 her husband’s body was removed from Cedar Hill for reburial at Walnut Hills Cemetery.

A Period of Growth: Jewish Arrivals in the Upper Miami Valley in the Late 19th Century

By 1875 the number of Anshe Emeth members had grown to 12 adults, and the
congregation relocated to a new building on West High Street at the northwest corner of Public
Square. This building, which was owned by Aaron Friedlich, was three stories tall and the
congregation met inside one of the upper halls.^[36] It was also in this same year that Congregation
Anshe Emeth was first incorporated with the State of Ohio.^[37] Newer Jewish residents in the
Upper Miami Valley around this time included Julia and Samuel Epstein, Jeanette and Louis
Hebel, Marcus Lebensburger and Meyer Newhoff. Julia and Samuel lived in Greenville while the
Hebels, Marcus and Meyer resided in Piqua. All of these individuals were involved in some
aspect of the clothing business. Samuel Epstein owned part of Bachman’s in the late 1870s and
for a time he was a business associate of Charles Bachman. In 1874, he ran a branch of Charles’
Elephant Clothing Store in Versailles.^[38] Louis Hebel was associated with the Bee Hive [sic]
clothing store. This shop appears to have been an early example of a chain store since other Bee
Hive clothing establishments existed across Ohio by the late 1800s. Marcus and Meyer did
business together at a clothing shop on North Main Street. During the late 1870s, the Jewish
population of the Upper Miami Valley appears to have remained fairly homogenous in terms of
ancestry and religious belief. Most, if not all, Jews in the area were recent immigrants from
German-speaking areas of Europe or the children of these immigrants. Almost everyone also
practiced the more liberal form of Judaism taught at the recently established Hebrew Union
College in Cincinnati.

This teaching, which was known as Reform Judaism, emphasized Judaism’s ethical
precepts over religious laws and sought to make Jewish practice more compatible with the
realities of life in the United States. Liturgical changes advocated by many Reform Jews during
the late 1800s included mixed seating in synagogues, the introduction of organs and other
instruments into religious services, and the abolition of head coverings during services.
Congregation Anshe Emeth was among the pioneers of Reform Judaism in America. In 1873 the
congregation became a charter member of the newly organized Union of American Hebrew
Congregations. This organization, now known as the Union for Reform Judaism, continues to
exist well into the 21st century and Anshe Emeth has maintained its membership. Anshe Emeth
was also among the first congregations to host visiting student rabbis from Hebrew Union
College, a tradition that continues as of 2021. Most
religious Jews living in the United States in 1880 believed
Reform Judaism to be the future of American Judaism.
Back in Europe, however, events in the Russian Empire
were about to usher in the largest wave of Jewish
immigration to the Americas yet seen. These immigrants
would change the course of American Jewish cultural and
religious life. Some eventually found their way to the
Upper Miami Valley, where they would contribute
significantly to Jewish history in the area.

 

Beginning in 1881, increased violence against Jews began to occur in many areas of
Eastern Europe due to political turmoil combined with longstanding prejudices. This violence
sometimes took the form of organized riots which became known as pogroms. Many Jews were
killed during these violent outbursts and thousands of families were made homeless. Violence,
compounded by oppressive laws, eventually compelled over two million Jews to immigrate to
the United States by 1924. While more wanted to leave Europe after 1924, the Johnson-Reed
Act, which was passed by Congress to limit further immigration from eastern and southern
Europe, caused a sharp decline in the number of new Jewish immigrants. Relations between the
new Eastern European Jewish immigrants and the older, more established German-American
Jews were not always cordial. Much of the disagreement was caused by differences in religious
practice and economic status. Specifically, Eastern European Jews tended to practice Orthodox
Judaism and most were also poor. Some native-born Jews in the United States feared that the
religious conservatism of Eastern European Jews and their impoverished state would lead to an
increase in anti-Jewish sentiment locally. In an effort to avert this, Jewish organizations such as
B’nai B’rith and Hebrew Union College sought to provide some forms of financial relief and
education services to Eastern European Jews, but these efforts were often seen as paternalistic by
the immigrant communities.

One letter published in the American Israelite by Abraham Herzstam, a clothing
merchant in Sidney, Ohio, in 1909 touches on some aspects of the interactions between Reform
and more orthodox Jews in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

If these pessimists [i.e. opponents of Reform Judaism] were here to see the many
beautiful temples, the interior decorations and furnishings, the families seated together,
hatless large congregations, hear the fine music and singing during services, they would
be astounded – feel as if they were in a dream. They would then know what useless
apprehensions they had, how erroneously they predicted. There are plenty of crude and
queer ways left and more continually coming from abroad; many ways and actions are as
conspicuous as the uniforms of the police, which must be eliminated for our mutual good.
A nice, bright, intelligent looking young man (lately from Russia, now residing in
Toledo, O.) passed through here recently buying old clothes. I said to him “You appear to
have good talent; why not try for a scholarship in the Hebrew Union College? That would
surely better your condition.” He replied: “I was offered the opportunity, but my father
objected, saying he would prefer to see me in the grave than to have me enter this
“Goyim college”. Is such ignorance bliss?^[39]

Abraham was an immigrant from Baden, which is located in what is now southwestern
Germany, and he lived in Sidney since the late 1870s. During the 1880s and 1890s, most new
Jewish families arriving in the Upper Miami Valley continued to come from German-Jewish,
Reform backgrounds. These families included Harmon and Sarah Bornstein, Betty and Gus
Felheim, and Herman and Julia Sternberger. Both Harmon and Gus owned businesses in
Greenville. Harmon managed Bornstein’s Barrel House, a liquor store located at the back of
Kipp’s Drug Store on Public Square. In 1886, Harmon sold the store to Max Ostheimer of
Cincinnati, who may also have been Jewish. Gus, who was a member of the Masons for 48
years, was associated with the Cincinnati Cheap Store, which sold dry goods.^[40] In 1887 Gus sold
his store to John Martin and Frank Gorden and went into the clothing business.^[41] He also
developed interests in the tobacco business. Sixteen years later the Felheim family moved to
Cincinnati. Herman Sternberger, who was a resident of Piqua by 1883, co-owned a music hall in
town and he was involved in other properties.^[42] These real estate interests included a mattress
factory on West Water Street and a portion of Fountain Park and the Forest Hotel.^[43] Herman was
also active in the Democratic Party and he served as an elector for the State of Ohio in the 1892
presidential campaign.^[44] Julia Sternberger was the daughter of Isaac and Regina Horkheimer,
who were connected with the Jewish community in Wheeling, West Virginia. By 1897, Julia and
her husband relocated to that city.

Due to the continued growth of the Jewish community in the Upper Miami Valley, a Sunday School was
established by the members of Anshe Emeth by 1880. In this same year, the
Union of American Hebrew Congregations estimated that 20
students were enrolled in the school and that Piqua’s overall
adult Jewish population stood at 26.^[45] It is likely, based on
activity at other Ohio congregations, that the ladies of Anshe
Emeth took a leading role in organizing the Sunday School.
No record of a formal Jewish women’s organization in the
area exists, however, until 1901 when a chapter of the Council
of Jewish Women, a national organization, was formed in
Piqua.^[46]46 The group, which met monthly, was composed of 21
women in its first year, and it was formed with the help of supporters from Cincinnati.^[47] Caroline
Flesh, the wife of Henry Flesh, served as the group’s first president, and Irma Louis, the wife of
Abraham Louis, was elected as the first vice president. The executive board was completed by
Flora Wendel, who served as treasurer, and Nannie LeBolt, the first secretary. Other members
included Isabelle Lazaron, Rose Louis, Rita Marks, Bernice Silberberg, Minnie Silberberg,
Bertha Urbansky, and Esther Urbansky. Council members helped to raise funds for the Jewish
Consumptive Relief Society in Denver, which built a hospital to treat patients from all
backgrounds, and supported other charitable causes.

Around 1882 members of Anshe Emeth began to organize weekly Shabbat services in
Piqua. Never before had Jewish religious services been held so frequently in the Upper Miami
Valley. In 1893, Anshe Emeth moved its location once again. The congregation was now
operating out of a rented hall located at 266 West High Street above Beck’s Commercial
College.^[48]Anshe Emeth remained here until 1923 when the synagogue on Caldwell Street was
constructed. Young Jewish adults in Piqua were also finding ways to connect with each other,
and with other Jews from surrounding towns. Among the social events organized in the 1880s
were dances that drew guests from various communities, including Bellefontaine, Delaware, and
Springfield.^[49]49 Individuals from small towns outside the Miami Valley were also affiliated with
Anshe Emeth. During the mid-1880s, it is known that some Jewish families from Delaware
traveled around 75 miles one way to attend holiday services at Anshe Emeth.^[50] This not only
demonstrates the challenges Jews in that community underwent to attend public religious
services on holidays, but also the rarity of synagogues in the wider region. It should be noted,
however, that Jews in Springfield formed a religious community in 1866.^[51] Construction on
Lima’s first synagogue, however, did not begin until 1914.^[52]

Among those who contributed to the development of communal, economic and Jewish
religious life in the Upper Miami Valley by the 1880s were the children of the earliest Jewish
residents of the region. One of the most notable households was the Flesh family. In 1863 Henry
Flesh married Caroline Friedlich, the eldest daughter of Emma and Moses Friedlich, and the
couple had at least three children. Their names were Leo, William, and Joel. While William
eventually moved to New York, Leo and Joel remained in Piqua and entered into various
business interests associated with their father. As mentioned previously, Henry Flesh began his
time in Piqua as a clothing merchant, and his store became well known throughout Miami
County. By the late 1860s, Henry’s business interests had expanded to include banking and
furniture manufacturing. For over 50 years, Henry was involved with Citizens National Bank.
This involvement included serving as the bank’s president for many years.^[53] Henry was also
associated with the Border City Building and Loan Association, which was established in Piqua
in 1882.^[54] He would serve as this company’s president for over 30 years. Henry’s role in local
furniture manufacturing stemmed from his work with the Cron-Kills Company, which he also
served as president for several years. Leo followed his father into the clothing and banking
business and eventually, he too would serve as president of Citizens National Bank.^[55] Leo was
also the president of the Atlas Underwear Company from 1900 to 1928. Atlas, which was
founded in 1899 as the Piqua Underwear Company, would grow to become one of Miami
County’s largest employers by the mid-20th century. Its plant, located at the corner of Downing
and Rundle Avenue, was the largest in the world devoted
exclusively to the manufacture of union suits.^[56] Joel went into the
furniture manufacturing business and served as vice president of
Cron-Kills.^[57]

Members of the Flesh family were also involved in a variety of
civic and community organizations. Caroline Flesh was active in
an interfaith organization known as the Associated Charities,
which held its first meeting in 1904. At the meetings, she
represented Anshe Emeth.^[58] Henry served on Piqua’s City
Council for 25 years and for part of this time was the body’s
president.^[59] Henry also served terms as president and treasurer
of the Piqua Board of Trade, a precursor to the contemporary
Chamber of Commerce, secretary of Anshe Emeth and master of the local Masonic lodge.
Additionally, among the projects Henry worked on were creating the Piqua-Troy rail line, helping
to bring electricity to Piqua and organizing the Piqua ElectricCompany, and establishing the Piqua
Memorial Hospital, which opened in 1905.^[60] Leo and Joel Flesh
were active in various community organizations,
including the Elks and Masons. Leo was also a supporter of
public education. This interest was expressed most notably
through his support of the Schmidlapp Free School Library,
which was renamed the Flesh Public Library in 1931
following a major donation by Leo.

While most of the Lebolt children moved away from Piqua
shortly after reaching adulthood, one son, Meyer, remained in
town long enough to have a family of his own. Meyer, who was also
known as May, was married to Rebecca Lebolt and the couple had
at least two children, Alice and Irma. Both daughters were students at the Anshe Emeth Sunday School.
Like his father, Charles, Meyer was involved in the grocery business and he may have operated the same
business on College Street. In 1907, however, Meyer sold the
grocery store to Calvin McCracken and the family seems to have
left Miami County soon after. Two years later, Rebecca died and
was buried at Cedar Hill. During Meyer’s time in Piqua, he served
terms as president of the Retail Merchants Protective Association
and as Nobel Grand of the Odd Fellows.^[61]

David and Regina Louis had five children, Abraham, Leo, Meyer,
Raphael, and Rose. Abraham married Irma Volmer of Cincinnati in 1898,
and, around this same time, he managed a clothing store named Flesh & Louis,
alongside Leo Flesh. It is also of note that Irma’s brother, Leon, who was a rabbi
in Charleston, West Virginia, occasionally visited Piqua to see family and
conduct services at Anshe Emeth. In 1910 Irma died, and Abraham eventually
moved to NewYork City where he represented the Atlas Underwear Company in business dealings. Leo
followed his father into the grocery business and eventually associated his store with the national
chain, Piggly-Wiggly.^[62] He also expanded his business to Sidney. Leo was married to Blanche
Wallbrunn, who was an active leader in the local Jewish community. Meyer and Raphael were
the oldest children of David and Regina and the two brothers partnered in business for much of
their lives. Early in their working years, the brothers owned a jewelry store, and later they
formed the Louis Metal and Iron Company, which sold scrap metals.^[63] Their most notable
business achievement, however, came in 1908 when Meyer and Raphael established the Piqua
Paper Box Company, which continues to exist well
into the 21st century.^[64]

Before moving into the 20th century, it is worth
noting that a number of Jewish families in Auglaize
County had personal or professional ties to members
of Piqua’s Jewish community during the late
19th-century. While located outside the Miami
Valley, these ties to Piqua merit mention. By the
mid-1870s Lena and Sol Bamberger were living in St
Marys with their children. It is likely that the family
was supported by a clothing business. Twenty years
later, another member of the Bamberger family, Herman,
who may have been a brother of Sol, lived in Greenville with
his wife Matilda and their six children. Around this same time, Sol was active in creating a telephone
company in St Marys.^[65] Most of the Bambergers appear to have left St Marys by 1910, but one,
Louis Bamberger, remained until at least the late 1920s. Louis was the son of Lena and Sol and he
was married to Elsie Spier, a native of Connecticut. In addition to serving as president of the local
Retail Merchants Association, Louis was also active with the Ohio Retail Clothiers and Furnishers Association.^[66]

To the east of St Marys in Wapakoneta lived Moses and Rosa Hirsch, Abraham and Rose
Kahn, Frederika and Nathan Kusel, and Adolph and Henrietta Steinberg. Moses and Rosa lived
in Wapakoneta with their son, David, by 1880. The family was supported by Moses’ work as a
clothier. Abraham Kahn was an immigrant from Alsace who came to the United States in 1869.
Shortly after he arrived in Wapakoneta, where he was likely met by relatives, including a
sister-in-law named Sarah Kahn. Abraham at first worked as a dry goods merchant and later
began a manufacturing business that produced farm tools and handles.^[67] In 1888, Abraham
married Rose Friedlich, a daughter of Aaron and Theresa, at a ceremony held at Friedlich home
in Piqua. Rabbi Mayer Messing of the Indianapolis Hebrew Congregation officiated. Frederika
and Nathan lived in Wapakoneta by the late 1870s and the couple supported their family through
Nathan’s work as a cattle dealer. Nathan’s life was cut short, however, in 1883 after he was
struck by a train. Following Nathan’s death, Frederika worked to support her five children.
Frederika died seven years after her husband and her two youngest children, Leon and Albert,
went to live at the Jewish Orphan Asylum in Cleveland.^[68] Adolph and Henrietta, who were both
immigrants from Central Europe, were wed in 1867 and they made their first home together in
New Bremen, Ohio.^[69] Here Adolph operated a clothing business and later sold produce. The
couple also had six children. In 1893 the family moved to Wapakoneta, where Adolph opened a
hotel by 1900.^[70] While Wapakoneta’s Jewish population was never more than a handful of
families, more Jews would find their way to the town in the early 20th century.

Growing Visibility: Jewish Life in the Upper Miami Valley During the Early 20th Century

Around 1900 it was estimated that Piqua’s Jewish families numbered approximately 12.^[71]
While Piqua’s Jewish community did not exceed more than 1 percent of the city’s overall
population, it was nonetheless the largest Jewish community in the Upper Miami Valley and it
held a visible presence in the overall community. Local newspapers, including The Piqua Daily
Call, regularly ran articles on the various Jewish holidays and carried news about Jewish
communities in other parts of the United States and abroad. The reporting found within local
newspapers, however, was not always accurate. For example, on September 12, 1901, The Piqua
Daily Call carried an article highlighting the observance of Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New
Year. In it the author remarked, “…the ram’s horn or ‘shofar’ is sounded as significant of the
throwing off of Pharaoh’s power from over Israel and the Lord’s ‘deliverance of his chosen
people’ from their bondage and slavery.”^[72] This explanation of the shofar was not correct. The
shofar in ancient times was used to announce the arrival of various religious holidays and the
beginning of a new king’s reign. Its use has been preserved in Jewish communities during the
month leading up to Rosh Hashanah and on the holiday itself to alert attendees at religious
services of the importance of the time and of sincere repentance. The Piqua Daily Call’s error
was remarked on by the editors of The Hebrew Standard in New York City, who included it
along with erroneous quotes about Rosh Hashanah from other national papers.^[73]

This story illustrates that while Judaism was regarded as an important piece of the faith
community in the Upper Miami Valley, the more detailed aspects of the faith and its rituals were
not always understood by non-Jews. In addition to marking the annual observance of Rosh
Hashanah, another holiday tradition maintained by the members of Anshe Emeth was conducting
confirmation exercises on Shavuot for the graduates of the congregation’s Sunday School.
Unlike blowing the shofar, however, the practice of confirming young Jews had modern origins
stemming from the Reform movement. The adoption of a confirmation ritual represents how
some Jewish communities took certain Christian customs and rituals and incorporated them into
Judaic religious life. Shavuot is itself an ancient biblical holiday that developed originally to
mark the harvest time in Israel. In later centuries after the exile of Jews from Israel, the holiday
also came to celebrate the anniversary of the Torah being received by the Israelites at Mt. Sinai.
It is for this reason that many Reform communities selected Shavuot as the day to confirm young
Jews. Confirmation classes at Anshe Emeth were of modest size. For example, in 1911 five
young people were confirmed by the congregation.^[74]

Adult religious education was not neglected by members of Anshe Emeth. By 1902 some
Jewish women in Piqua were meeting for weekly Bible study.^[75] Around this same time, the
members of the Council of Jewish Women reorganized themselves as the Jewish Ladies’ Aid
Society. This women’s group sponsored social activities to raise funds for charity and organized
a weekly “Thimble Social” in member’s homes where needed items were created for local
charities.^[76] Over the years, these charities included the Jewish Infant’s Home in Cleveland, Piqua
Memorial Hospital, and the Red Cross. Caroline Flesh hosted the first recorded Thimble Social
at her home in February 1903 and these socials continued into the 1930s. The Ladies’ Aid
Society also supported the Anshe Emeth Sunday School and sponsored public lectures on Jewish
history and theology. The Society’s educational work included raising funds to purchase books
on Jewish subjects for Piqua’s public library. By 1913 the Society had 15 or 16 members and it
formally joined the National Federation of Temple Sisterhoods in this same year.^[77]

Between the years 1895 and 1917 several new Jewish families arrived in the Upper
Miami Valley. It is also likely that these years represented the peak time for Jewish immigration
to the region. New Jewish families in Piqua included the surnames Dagan, Kastner, Katz, Marks
Mickler, Ostertag, Shuchat, and Yassenoff. Fannie and Solomon Dagan arrived in Piqua by 1910.
Both were immigrants from Europe, and like many Jewish immigrants to the United States at the
time their family was supported through Solomon’s work in the scrap metal industry. Solomon’s
business, Ohio Scrap Iron and Metal Company, was located at 651 West Water Street. By 1914,
Solomon’s business had earned the family enough money that Solomon was able to own a piece
of real estate on Main Street. This property was rented to Fannie’s brother, Harry Mickler, who
co-founded the Mickler Department Store around 1914 with his brother, John. Harry had moved
to Piqua by 1907 with his parents, Abram and Celia, and two younger brothers, Edward and
Moses. At the time, Abram and his children operated Mickler & Sons, a clothing store located at
326 North Main. In 1917, John moved to Springfield, Ohio, with his new wife, Sarah, who was a
previous resident of Lexington, Kentucky.^[78] Eventually, the other Mickler brothers would also
depart from Piqua.

Joseph and Sara Kastner lived in Piqua by 1917, and Joseph supported his growing
family through his work selling scrap metal. Joseph’s business was named the St. Louis Iron and
Metal Company and it was originally located along Covington Avenue. By 1920, Joseph was
joined by his brother, Samuel, and the business informally became known as Kastner Brothers.
Joseph and Samuel were immigrants from Ukraine while Sara was born in London, England.
Joseph and Sara were wed in 1914. By this time, Sara lived in Xenia, Ohio.^[79] Joseph, Sara, and
Samuel were all active members of the Piqua community, and Joseph was posthumously
inducted into the Piqua Civic Hall of Fame.^[80] Joseph and Sara supported the Red Cross and
Y.M.C.A., and Samuel, together with his wife Dina, was active with the Red Cross and
Inter-Church Council. Like the Kastner brothers, Samuel and Milton Katz were siblings who
moved to Piqua with their wives, Alma and Florence, to grow a business. This business was the
Katz Brothers Clothing Store, and it was
opened in April 1910.^[81] Both brothers,
however, left Piqua with their wives by 1920.
Louis Marks, Bert Ostertag, and Louis
Ostertag were also contemporary clothing
merchants in Piqua. The Ostertag Brothers
firm, founded in 1895, would remain a fixture
on Main Street for 47 years.^[82]

When Israel Charles Shuchat moved
to Piqua with his wife Dora in 1914 to open a
dry cleaning business, it represented one of
the first enterprises of its kind in the city.
Shuchat’s remained in business for over 60
years, and it would become one of the largest dry cleaning operations in the county. Charles and
Dora had three children, Joseph, Samuel and Trina. Joseph went on to become a podiatrist, or
foot doctor, in Piqua for over 55 years, while Samuel carried on the family tradition of dry
cleaning. At first, Samuel worked in Piqua and later he oversaw the relocation of the family
business to Sidney, where it was known as One Hour Cleaners. Shortly after graduating from
Piqua High School, Trina moved to Chicago. It is of note that descendants of Charles and Dora
continue to work in Sidney and their business, Clean All Services, employs
around 280 people.^[83]

The last Jewish couple in Piqua which will be discussed in this section is Carrie and Isaac
Yassenoff. While the Yassenoffs did not remain in Piqua for very long, one of their sons, Leo,
went on to become a notable philanthropist within the Columbus Jewish community, and this
connection to Columbus merits mention. Carrie and Isaac settled in Piqua by 1895, and Isaac
found work selling hides, pelts, and scrap metals. While Carrie was an immigrant from
southwest Germany, Isaac was born in Ukraine. It is likely that Isaac was among the first Eastern
European Jews to live in Piqua. The Yassenoffs had at least three children, Leo, Rebecca, and
Solomon, and all were born in Piqua. Around 1912 the family relocated to Columbus. Leo would
become quite wealthy through his role as co-founder of the F & Y Construction Company, which
began business in 1919.^[84]

Sidney and Troy were also home to recent Jewish immigrant families during this same
time period.  In Sidney lived David and Louis Halverstein. These men, who were likely brothers,
worked in the clothing business. Some sources also spell their surname Halberstein. By the
mid-1930s, David moved to St Marys with his wife, Molly, while Louis remained in Sidney with
Rosa, his wife.^[84] One son of David and Molly, Joseph, went on to write for the Lima News as a
sports journalist. Another son, Marvin, also went into journalism. Twenty miles south of Sidney
in Tory there lived Jacob Stayman. Jacob arrived from Dayton in 1913, and prior to Dayton, he
lived in Russia, where a wife and children still resided.^[86] Jacob found work in Troy as a scrap
metal trader, and, following World War I, he was joined in town by his sons, Philip and Samuel,
and a daughter, Helen. His first wife, however, died in Europe during the war.

On March 25, 1913, the Miami Valley was visited by one of the worst floods on record.
Piqua was hit particularly hard, and at least 38 residents died.^[87] The deluge was part of a larger
series of flooding disasters that struck Ohio that same year. Among the organizations that
mobilized to provide relief for flood victims was the Ladies’ Aid Society.^[88] Four years later, the
lives of many residents of the Upper Miami Valley were again uprooted due to the onset of
World War I, which the United States entered on April 6, 1917. Among the locals who entered
the service were at least three Jews. Their names were David Halverstein, Samuel Louis, and
Moses Mickler. It is also of note that two sons of Leo Flesh, Alfred and George, served during
the war, but they did not practice Judaism. Leo’s wife, Gertrude, was a Christian and the Flesh
children were raised in that faith. Leo, however, maintained a connection to the Jewish
community throughout his life. When Leo was buried in 1944 both Christian and Jewish funeral
rites were used.^[89] Efforts were also made on the home front to support the war effort, and Jews
contributed to both local and national activities. Fannie Louis and Leo Louis were active with the
local Red Cross, while Leo Flesh lent his efforts to the textile division of the Council for
National Defense. Members of the Jewish community also came together in 1916 to raise funds
to support refugees in Europe and Palestine.^[90]

During or immediately after World War I a few new Jewish families arrived in Piqua.
These families included the Funderburgs and Polaskys. In 1917, Kline and Stella Funderburg
relocated to Piqua after Kline took a position as the manager of the Peoples Credit Clothing
Company. This clothing store was part of a chain headquartered in Dayton, and the Funderburg
family remained in Piqua until 1935 when Kline took a position with headquarters.^[91] Harry and
Rebecca Polasky arrived in Piqua by 1919. At first, Harry found work as a tailor, and later he
opened a clothing store on North Wayne Street. Both new and old families helped to ensure the
continuation of Jewish communal life in the Upper Miami Valley during the 1910s. Throughout
this period, Emanuel Kahn served as rabbi of Anshe Emeth. It was not a rabbinic post, however,
that brought Emanuel to Piqua. Emanuel, who was also known as Manuel, was born in
Cincinnati and graduated from Hebrew Union College. Prior to relocating to Piqua in 1910, he
lived in Grand Rapids, Michigan where he served at Temple Emanu-El.^[92] Manuel was married to
Freda, an immigrant from Germany whose father, Jacob Wolf, and brother, Simon Wolf, both
lived in Miami County during the 1900s. Jacob and Samuel moved to Piqua around 1903 and
they operated a clothing store formerly owned by Meyer Newhoff. When Jacob retired and
Samuel moved away, the business passed to Manuel. Now named E. Kahn & Company, the
business would remain a fixture on North Main Street for several decades.

A Synagogue on Caldwell Street: The Dedication of Congregation Anshe Emeth

On April 2, 1923, Congregation Anshe Emeth was dedicated at 320 Caldwell Street.
Approximately 250 people, including many non-Jews, were estimated to have attended the
ceremonies. At the time Piqua was home to around 25 Jewish families.^[93] Other members of the
congregation came from Greenville, Sidney and Troy. It was reported by The Piqua Daily Call
that Miami County was home to the smallest Jewish community in the United States to build a
synagogue.^[94] Rabbi Samuel Mayerberg of Dayton was an ardent supporter of Anshe Emeth
during the fundraising campaign for the new synagogue. He also officiated at the cornerstone
laying ceremony for the synagogue in 1922, which was open to the public. Remarking on the
event, Rabbi Mayerberg wrote in the Ohio Jewish Chronicle:

Piqua is an inspiration. The erection of a new house of worship in that small community
is an inspiration to all Jews. There are only a few Jews in Piqua… Our co-religionists of
that small community are therefore to be congratulated upon their achievement… One
may wonder how so few people can accomplish so much. The answer is simple.
Co-operation, unity, and harmony among the people have made their dreams of a house
of worship a reality.^[95]

Rabbi Mayerberg’s insight into the members of Anshe Emeth stemmed from his
ministerial work in Piqua, which began at least a few years before the building of the new
synagogue. He visited Miami County monthly to teach adult Bible classes and met with students
at the weekly Sunday School. Jewish religious services were held every Friday evening and on
Sundays twice a month. All this activity led Mayerberg in one letter published in August 1922 to
describe Anshe Emeth as “a model small town congregation.”^[96] It should also be noted that
Rabbi Sidney Tedesche of Springfield also occasionally visited Piqua to lead religious services
and speak to the Anshe Emeth Sunday School students.^[97] At the time, he was one of two rabbis
in that city.

Building the new Anshe Emeth synagogue cost approximately $20,000. In 2021, this sum
would be comparable to $320,400 after accounting for inflation. Half of the necessary funds
were donated by Leo Flesh.^[98] The other $10,000 was raised by a wide collection of individuals
including most notably the members of the Anshe Emeth Sisterhood, which was formerly known
as the Jewish Ladies’ Aid Society. Fundraisers for the construction project organized by the
Sisterhood included four bake sales, four dinners, a series of rummage sales, and raffles.^[100] The
efforts of the Sisterhood, which helped to ensure the new synagogue could be created free of
debt, were recognized by similar organizations in other nearby Jewish communities. In 1922,
Piqua was selected as the site of the district meeting for the Ohio State Federation of Temple
Sisterhoods, drawing many people from Dayton and Springfield.^[101] Members of the Sisterhood,
which in 1920 had 15 members, also continued to support the Anshe Emeth Sunday School. In
1922, two children were confirmed from the school. The students and teachers also led special
Hanukkah and Passover services.^[102] By 1924, the Sisterhood had created a new library at Anshe
Emeth for the Sunday School.^[103]

During this period in the Sisterhood’s history Fannie Louis, the wife of Meyer Louis,
served as president of the organization. When the new Anshe Emeth synagogue was dedicated,
Fannie was honored by being chosen to kindle the ner tamid, or eternal light found at the front of
the sanctuary. A ner tamid is found in most synagogues near the Torah ark and it serves to
remind congregants of the continuous presence of the divine. Interestingly, Fannie was a native
of Delaware, Ohio, and her parents, Rachel and Samuel Stern, were likely among those who
traveled significant distances in the late 1800s to attend Anshe Emeth on holidays. Rachel’s
maiden name was Friedlich. The officers of Congregation Anshe Emeth in 1923 were as follows:
Moses Flesh, president, Jacob Wendel, vice president, Meyer Louis, secretary, and Louis
Ostertag treasurer. It is of note that Louis Ostertag served as treasurer of the congregation from
1918 up until 1947.^[104] In 1924, Raphael Louis took on the role of president of the congregation
and retained this position until 1947, when he was succeeded by Joseph Kastner and elected
honorary president for life.^[105] Raphael’s brother, Meyer, frequently served as a lay leader in the
new synagogue. In some advertisements published in The Piqua Daily Call Meyer’s title is given
as Reader.

Anshe Emeth was reincorporated with the State of Ohio in 1924. The signatories of the
congregation’s new Articles of Incorporation were: Moses Flesh, Marcus A. Lebensburger, Leo
Louis, Meyer Louis, and Louis Ostertag. The Jewish community of the Upper Miami Valley also
continued to keep informed of events impacting their coreligionists abroad during this period. In
1926, the local Jewish families raised $4,721 to support Jews suffering in Europe.^[106] Local
developments also included the arrival of several new Jewish families in the region. In Piqua
newcomers included Frances and Robert F. Albright, David and Grace Hirsch, and Benjamin and
Ray Kuppin. The Albright family came to Piqua after Robert, who more commonly went by his
middle name Frank, became associated with the Rapp’s Clothing Store. David Hirsch moved to
Piqua with his wife and son, Allen, in 1925 to take a position with the Cottage Baking Company.
The family remained in Piqua until 1934 but maintained close connections with the Columbus
Jewish community.^[107] In 1931, Allen had his bar mitzvah at Congregation Agudas Achim in
Columbus. Benjamin and Ray Kuppin were living in Piqua by 1920, and by 1930 Ben was
running the Eagle Billiard Hall. The couple also had at least four children, Bertram, Frank,
Hannah and Herbert. All of these children moved away from Piqua as adults.

Jews also continued to move into Greenville, Sidney and Troy. New residents included
Simon Brotkin, Freda and Harris Harbor, Minnie and Morris Jaffe, Morris and Rose Kaufman
and Abraham and Lena Rokoff. Simon, who was nicknamed Si, moved to Greenville from
Massachusetts in the late 1920s to work with the Greenville Iron and Metal Company, which was
owned by an uncle.^[107] Later, in 1937, he opened The Smart Shop, which was located along South
Broadway.^[108] This store sold women’s clothing, and later children’s wear. In time, Simon helped
his brother, Isidore, open a branch of The Smart Shop in Sidney, and a branch was also opened in
Piqua, where Simon moved following his marriage to Sara Rosenblatt. Sara was from Tiffin,
Ohio.^[109] Max Brotkin, the father of Simon, also moved to Greenville to help run the store there.
He was joined by Ida, his wife.^[110]

Both the Harbors in Troy and the Jaffes in Greenville were active in the scrap metal
industry. Much like the clothing industry for earlier Jewish immigrants, the disproportionate
presence of Jews in the scrap metal industry was due to the recent development of the trade and
its accessibility to immigrants at a time when discrimination closed many other professional
avenues. Operating a scrap yard was also particularly attainable for many Jewish immigrants
because of its low startup cost and scalability. Religious entrepreneurs could also create their
own work schedules around holidays and other observances which would not have been
permitted in larger factories. By 1930 Fortune magazine estimated that 90 percent of scrap metal
yards in the United States were owned by Jews.^[111] Harris Harbor’s business was known as Harris
Harbor Recycling while Morris Jaffe’s enterprise was called Greenville Iron & Metal Company.
Morris Kaufman of Sidney and Abraham Rokoff of Troy worked as clothiers. The tradition of
enterprise within the local Jewish community would continue into the 1930s, but challenges
would impact more than one family.

The Depression & War Years: Jewish Life in the Upper Miami Valley in the ‘30s and ‘40s

On January 29, 1930, the three-story Mickler Department Store on Main Street
experienced a major fire that began in the basement. The damages were estimated to be
$200,000.^[112] This sum would be comparable to over $3,200,000 in losses in 2021. In addition to
the Mickler store, Ostertag Brothers, located next door, was also impacted. At the time, Kenneth
Shofstall, a reporter for The Piqua Daily Call, reported that the blaze was, “one of the most
disastrous fires in the history of the city.”^[113] Within three weeks Bert and Louis Ostertag made
plans to relocate to a space in the Piqua National Bank building with a new stock of
merchandise.^[114] Harry Mickler was able to rebuild his store, but in 1935 he declared
bankruptcy.^[115] He departed Piqua for Columbus by 1938.

It appears that Harry was not the only Jew to leave the Upper Miami Valley during the
1930s. In 1930, the American Jewish Yearbook, which continues to be printed annually by the
Jewish Publication Society, estimated that the Piqua area was home to 90 Jews.^[116] By 1941 this
estimate had fallen to 75.^[117] The adult Jewish population within Piqua alone was estimated to
number 20 in 1937.^[118] It should be noted, however, that these population estimates are useful
only for providing a general sense of the Jewish community’s size. It is likely, however, that the
estimates are not entirely accurate since determining the size of any religious community in the
United States is a challenge due to the lack of official data on the subject. It is even more
difficult to accurately assess the size of a minority religious community whose members may
feel hesitant to answer questionnaires or publicly affiliate.

While undoubtedly modest in size, the Jewish community participated actively in
interfaith activities in Piqua. By the late 1930s, an Inter-Church Council existed which included
Anshe Emeth as a member. Non-Jewish ministers were also invited to speak at Anshe Emeth.^[119]
Similarly, rabbis were invited to address primarily non-Jewish audiences on occasion. For
example, in 1932 Rabbi Jacob Tarshish of Columbus spoke at the graduation exercises for Piqua
High School.^[120] While religious tolerance generally was practiced, there were contemporary
examples of anti-Jewish sentiment in the region. Clara Ziment, who grew up in Piqua during the
1920s and 1930s, wrote in a 2012 essay on her spiritual journey that Jewish children in Piqua
were sometimes harassed and hit by Catholic school students who were taught at the time that
Jews were responsible for the death of Jesus Christ. Clara also wrote that she experienced some
indirect comments in the local public schools about her difference as a Jew.^[121] Clara is the
daughter of Dina and Samuel Kastner and, after graduating from Piqua High School, she
attended the Art Academy of Cincinnati and later the Pratt Institute in New York City. She had a
successful career as a cartoon artist.

Congregation Anshe Emeth continued to be a center for Jewish life, attracting members
from across Miami County and surrounding areas. By the mid-1930s, some congregants were
coming from Urbana to the east.^[122] The Sisterhood worked to support congregational activities
by organizing card parties, the occasional rummage sale and other fundraisers. Its members also
continued to support the Sunday School and its confirmation classes. In 1941, two children were
confirmed at Anshe Emeth, Bertram Kuppin and Mildred Murstein.^[123] No record of a local
Jewish men’s organization exists, however, until April 13, 1944. On this day the Anshe Emeth
Lodge, also known as Lodge 1523, of B’nai B’rith was formed.^[124] Representatives from the Zion
Lodge in Columbus assisted with the installation ceremony. Early members came from Covington, Greenville,
Piqua, Sidney, St. Paris, Troy, Urbana, and Versailles.^[125] By 1951, the
lodge had around 25 members. By 1945, a Women’s Auxiliary was also formed to complement
the activities of the men’s lodge.^[126]

A number of Jewish families are known to have moved to the Piqua area in the 1930s.
Included among them are the Bettmann, Brateman, Fishel, Gilfer, Lee, Murstein, Perlis,
Solomon, and Sussman households. Jacob and Helen Bettmann lived in Piqua only for a short
time after Jacob relocated in 1933 or 1934 due to his work with the Favorite Stove and Range
Company. Prior to this move, the couple had lived in Cincinnati.^[127] It should also be noted that
Jacob, who was a longtime member of the Favorite Stove board of directors, likely lived in Piqua
for a brief period in the early 1900s. For many years, Favorite Stove, which was originally based
in Cincinnati before moving to Piqua in 1887, was the city’s largest manufacturer.^[128] The
Depression severely impacted the company, however, and in 1935 the firm was liquidated. Most
of its former assets were purchased by the Foster Stove Company out of Ironton, Ohio.^[129] Jacob
died that same year at the age of 70. Helen, who had lived in St. Joseph, Missouri, before her
marriage in 1895 appears to have left the Piqua area after her husband’s death.^[130]

Herman Brateman, Trina Fishel, and Harry Gilfer all worked in the accessory or clothing
business. Brateman’s, a women’s and children’s clothing store located on South Broadway in
Greenville, was opened between 1939 and 1942. Trina worked at dress shops in both Piqua and
Sindey beginning in the mid-1930s before moving to Cleveland in 1951 to take a position with
Glanz Furs.^[131] Harry owned a men’s clothing and tailoring shop along North Main Avenue in
Sidney by 1936. Other recent arrivals in the area engaged in various kinds of work. Harry and
Jennie Lee, who lived in Covington by 1937 operated the Cove Theater in that town.^[132] Joseph,
the son of Harry and Jennie, also helped to manage the theater. Joe was active in the local
community. From 1945 to 1946 he served as the second president of the Anshe Emeth Lodge,
and his wife, Ruby, was active with the B’nai B’rith Woman’s Auxiliary. Joe was also the
co-owner and editor of Stillwater Valley News, a Covington newspaper. Elliott and Libbie
Murstein opened the Elliott Furniture Store in 1934 at the corner of West Ash and North Wayne
Street. This business continued in Piqua through the 1960s. In 1951, Louis and Mildred Berman
moved to Piqua from Cleveland to help run Elliott’s Furniture. Mildred was the daughter of
Elliott and Libbie. A few years later, Louis opened Elmur’s Furniture Store at the corner of East
High and Harrison Street, which he operated through 1963.^[133] Louis’ life was cut short in 1967 at
the age of 43 due to an auto accident on Interstate-75.^[134] At the time Louis was planning to open
a store in Dayton.

Dorothy and Seymour Perlis moved to Piqua from Toledo in 1938 to open a cleaning
business under the name XL Cleaners. In addition to his involvement with Anshe Emeth,
Seymour was also an early member of the Piqua Kiwanis Club, which was chartered in 1936.
Both Leonard Solomon and Harry Sussman were involved in the scrap metal industry. Leonard,
who was born in New Jersey, owned East Side Iron and Wrecking in Sidney. Later he also
opened another business, Leonard’s Auto Parts.^[135] Both Leonard and his wife, Sarah, were
members of Anshe Emeth. Sarah was also active with the B’nai B’rith Woman’s Auxiliary, while
Leonard volunteered with the Boy Scouts and the Sidney Lions Club.^[136] Harry Sussman moved
to Piqua in 1931 with his wife, Bessie, after spending seven years in Sidney. The couple
relocated so that Harry could take ownership of the Ohio Scrap Iron & Metal Company, which
had been founded by Solomon Dagan over 15 years prior. While residents of Piqua, it appears
that Bessie and Harry chose to attend Beth Abraham, a synagogue in Dayton, rather than Anshe
Emeth. Until 1943 Beth Abraham was an Orthodox synagogue.^[137] The Sussman’s decision to
attend Beth Abraham rather than a local synagogue demonstrates how many of the more
orthodox Jewish households in the Upper Miami Valley continued to look to Dayton for
communal religious life.

On December 7, 1941, Pearl Harbor was attacked and soon millions of Americans were
called upon to enter the armed forces. Families, both Jewish and non-Jewish, in the Upper Miami
Valley, lent their efforts to support the war effort. Of the local servicemen, at least 11 were
Jewish. Their names were: Herman Barr, Herman Brateman, Daniel Garfield, Marvin
Halverstein, Erving Kastner, Norman Kastner, Sanford Kastner, Bertram Kuppin, Frank Kuppin,
Joseph Shuchat, and Benjamin Taubman. It should also be noted that shortly after the end of
World War II two other Jewish veterans, Charles Bailen and Louis Berman, relocated to Troy and
Piqua, respectively. Louis was an ensign in the United States Navy. Additionally, Alfred Flesh Jr.
and Henry Flesh, the grandsons of Leo and Gertrude Flesh, served during the war. Alfred Jr. was
killed in action, and to honor his memory Alfred Flesh Sr. established the Alfred L. Flesh Jr.
Memorial Trust in 1946 to benefit local community projects and civic institutions. Alfred Jr.
fought in the Pacific Theater.^[138]

Other local Jewish servicemen saw action in the European Theater. Bertram Kuppin was
among these men. In 1945, Bertram was captured by the Nazis and held as a prisoner of war for
five months near Czechoslovakia before being released.^[139] By the war’s end, both of Bertram’s
parents had died and, shortly after returning to the United States he, along with his other siblings,
left Piqua. The Nazi’s rise to power 12 years earlier prompted a wave of emigration from
Germany. Yet, the United States, along with most other countries at the time, allowed only a
modest number of refugees to enter the country. After the outbreak of World War II, this number
further decreased. Two of the fortunate people granted admittance into the United States were
Arthur and Margaret Werner, who settled in Piqua in 1939. For many years in Germany Arthur
managed a chain of stores. By November 1938, however, the Nazis confiscated all remaining
Jewish-owned businesses in Germany. Arthur was imprisoned for three weeks in the
Buchenwald concentration camp in the same year. On April 20, 1945, The Piqua Daily Call
published a letter from Arthur reflecting on his experiences and responding to those who
believed that reports coming out of Europe about the concentration camps were exaggerated. He
wrote:

Every day [sic] people of this town ask me if such terrible happenings are true. They
believe those stories might be exaggerated. As matter of fact I have been an inmate of the
concentration camp ‘Buchenwald’ in 1938, and I can confirm that those reports are true,
without any doubt. The chance to get out of this camp alive is only 100 to 1. I saw with
my own eyes my fellow prisoners dying beside me the same way as Mr. Richards
describes it in your paper today. If somebody should still have doubts, please, send them
to me.^[140]

It is likely that Arthur and Margaret found their way to Piqua due to the support and
sponsorship of individuals from the local Jewish community. One group working to support
Jewish refugees at the time was the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee (JDC). Leo
Flesh and Emanuel Kahn were two residents of Piqua who were active with the JDC. In 1942,
each was elected to the organization’s National Council.^[141] It was also reported in the obituary of
Dina Kastner, written in 1990, that she assisted in the resettlement of two Jewish refugee families
from Germany.^[142] No contemporary sources, however, reference the existence of a refugee family
in Piqua aside from the Werners. Evident in Arthur’s letter to The Piqua Daily Call, is the
responsibility he took upon himself to bear witness to the atrocities committed by the Nazis in
Europe. Shortly after his letter was printed, Arthur spoke to a Lions Club meeting about his
experiences.^[143] Margaret also worked to educate others on what was happening in Europe. As
early as 1942 she was speaking to organizations about her experiences.^[144] When Arthur and
Margaret arrived in Piqua, they were 56 and 47 years old respectively. Arthur at first secured
employment with the Orr Felt and Blanket Company and later he went to work at Yieldmor
Feeds until his retirement in 1965. Margaret had died six years prior.

During the late 1940s to mid-1960s, the Jewish population of the Upper Miami Valley
reached its largest size. According to the American Jewish Yearbook, by 1959 the local Jewish
community may have numbered as high as 225 people.^[145] This number, however, was likely an
overestimation. A figure of 170 to 175, which is cited in other years, was likely closer to reality.
Families who arrived in Piqua between 1945 and 1950 included Charles and Zena Bailen,
Edward and Tillie Bailen, Elizabeth and Isaac Harrison, Bernice and Joe Klasman, and Bernice
and Maurice Schapiro. Charles and Edward Bailen did business together in Tory under the name
United Scrap Lead Company. Edward created the business and was later joined by his brother.
Elizabeth and Isaac Harrison, who were both natives of Cincinnati, moved to Piqua in 1947 after
Isaac began a new business venture, Barclay’s Menswear.^[146] In 1949, Stanley joined his father in
the business. The enterprise enjoyed continued growth and by the 1980s Barclay’s began to offer
women’s apparel and accessories. As of 2021, Barclay’s Men’s & Women’s Clothiers is the
largest independent family-owned clothing store in the Miami Valley.^[147]

Bernice and Joe Klasman also arrived in Piqua in 1947. The couple was brought to
Miami County after Joe took a position as city editor with The Piqua Daily Call. Before writing
in Piqua, Joe had experience reporting in East St. Louis, Huntington, Pittsburgh, and
Louisville.^[148] His early assignments in East St. Louis included covering gang violence and
executions.^[149] He would serve as the city editor for 28 years before retiring. Like Joe, Maurice
Schapiro worked as a newspaper reporter. He came to Miami County to take a position as the
Troy correspondent for the Dayton Daily News. Bernice and Maurice lived in Troy by 1947 and
they were involved in both Anshe Emeth and B’nai B’rith. Both organizations would see new
levels of activity during the 1950s and 1960s.

The Post-War Years: A Time of Expansion

Mirroring the community as a whole, the
1950s were a boom time for the Anshe Emeth
Sunday School as youths aged into their
schooling years. By 1954 Sunday School
students were coming from Greenville, Piqua,
Pitsburg, Sidney, and Troy.^[150] As families grew,
so too did Anshe Emeth and its resources. From
1950 to 1955 the congregation had enough funds
to secure the services of a Sunday School
principal, Morton Kanter. Prior to moving to
Piqua, Morton served in World War II and he was a Hillel
staff member at Miami University.^[151]
He was also a student at Hebrew Union College before being ordained in 1955. Morton left
Piqua later in that same year to take a position as assistant rabbi at Temple Israel in Dayton. The
growth of the Sunday School also contributed to the addition of a one-story kitchen and social
hall at the back of Anshe Emeth in 1958. This addition, which was built at the cost of $25,000,
was used to house the Sunday School’s classes and provide additional event space for the
congregation.^[152] Frank Albright and Seymour Perlis served as co-chairman of the building
committee.^[153] At the time, it was estimated Anshe Emeth had between 35 and 40 member
families.

The year 1958 also marked the centennial of Anshe Emeth, and the anniversary was
observed with appropriate functions. Rabbi Stanley
Chyet, a research fellow at the American Jewish
Archives in Cincinnati, was the principal speaker at
the congregation’s anniversary celebration.^[154] In
this same year, the congregation dedicated a new
Torah scroll, which was donated by Gertrude Flesh.
The Sisterhood, which sponsored events such as an
annual Purim dinner and Passover seder, also
expanded. Around 30 women were affiliated with the Sisterhood
during the mid-1950s. Presidents or past-presidents during this period included,
Jean Kahn, Blanche Louis, Libbie Murstein and Sally Shuchat. Libbie was
known in the local Jewish community for hosting an annual Rosh Hashanah
kiddush at her home in memory of her husband, Elliott, who died in
1955. This holiday gathering occurred at the Murstein home for at least 29 years.
Libbie’s legacy of hospitality continues into the 21st century
through the Libbie Murstein Hospitality Fund,
which supports onegs, or shared Shabbat
gatherings, and a communal break-the-fast meal
following Yom Kippur for Anshe Emeth
congregants.^[155]

B’nai B’rith also grew its activities. Members sponsored an annual dinner at Hotel Fort
Piqua, and in 1958 the lodge began a tradition of recognizing an annual “Man of the Year”.^[156]

Harry Bell, who was active in promoting local Community Chest fundraisers, was the
first recipient. Community Chest was a precursor to United Way. In 1959, Reverend
Albert Dixon, a Baptist minister in Troy received the award in recognition of his work
to promote public recreation.^[157] Presidents of B’nai B’rith during the 1950s and
1960s include Isadore Brotkin, Joseph Kastner, Elliott Murstein and Herbert Perlis.
Other members at the time were Louis Berman, Zale Freed, Samuel Freiberg, Clarence
Goldberg, Frank Greene, Herman Musman, Max Rose, David Saidelman, and Daniel Taubman.

It is of note that Clarence and his wife, Dottie, were residents of Pitsburg, Ohio.^[158] This
village, which was home to 359 people in 1950, is located southwest of Piqua. While Clarence
lived in Pitsburg, he worked in Laura, Ohio, at the Roark Furs and Roark Furniture companies.
In 1959, he retired and moved to Florida with Dottie. Retirements and young adults moving
away from the Upper Miami Valley would stagnate growth, and eventually diminish the size of
the local Jewish community by the early 1970s. This population trend was reflected in the area as
a whole. Piqua, Greenville, Sidney, and Troy all recorded slower levels of population growth
from 1960 to 1970 than they did in the decade between 1950 to 1960. Demographic stagnation
continued from 1970 to 1980, and in Piqua’s case there was a population decline of 1.3 percent.
The opening of Interstate 75 by the late 1960s also encouraged Jewish families in the Upper
Miami Valley to affiliate with synagogues in the Dayton area, which were larger and able to offer
a wider range of services.^[159] The Anshe Emeth B’nai B’rith lodge continued to be active into the
late 1970s, but it likely faded out during the 1980s.^[160] The Anshe Emeth Sisterhood likely ceased
to function by the early 1970s.

Developments in the Late 20th and Early 21st Centuries

While the Jewish community of the Upper Miami Valley was contracting by the late
1960s, newer arrivals did occasionally join Anshe Emeth. These individuals have included
Charles and Mildred Bader, Mike and Judy Feinstein, Eugene and Judy Horowitz, Eileen
Litchfield, and Patty and Steven Wyke. Additionally, some older families, such as the Kastners
and Shuchats continued to be active with Anshe Emeth. One member of the Shuchat family,
Steve, serves as president of Congregation Anshe Emeth in 2021. Despite the occasional arrival
of new Jewish residents, by the year 2000, the number of member families at Anshe Emeth had
fallen to 26.^[161] In 2021, this number had contracted to 20.^[162] Lay leaders have continued to play
an important part in congregational life. For decades Judy Feinstein was active in organizing the
Anshe Emeth religious school, which continued to function well into the 21st century.
Professionally, Judy worked as an elementary school teacher, and this background in education
informed how she organized the Sunday School.

Herman Barr assisted by teaching bar mitzvah students.
Herman also led religious services for years, including
periods when Anshe Emeth had too few active
members to support a student rabbi. During a stretch of
the 1970s, just five people were attending a typical
Friday night service at Anshe Emeth.^[163] For a time,
discussions were had about closing the synagogue. Two
Anshe Emeth leaders, Barbara Freed-Bollenbacher and
Max Rose worked to increase membership by conducting individual
outreach to Jewish families living in Darke County, Piqua, and Sidney.^[164]
Anshe Emeth also benefited from a partnership with Temple Israel
in Dayton whereby each congregation shared the proceeds from bingo nights.^[165]
Through this outreach and fundraising,
the financial outlook of Anshe Emeth improved, and by the mid-1980s the congregation was
again able to secure the services of visiting student rabbis. These students visited once a month
and on major Jewish holidays. The first student rabbi following the hiatus was named Sue Levi
Elwell. Sue was also the first female rabbi at Anshe Emeth.^[166]

Barbara, who converted to Judaism prior to her marriage to Fred Freed in 1972,
continued to maintain an active role in Anshe Emeth for many years. From 1982 to 1985 she
served as the congregation’s first female president. Max Rose, who owned a furniture store in
Sidney since 1946, was active in the Lions Club in addition to his work within the local Jewish
community. He was married to Helen. From 1986 to 1994, Mike Feinstein served as Anshe
Emeth’s president. Mike, who ran a dental practice in Troy for many years, continues to lead
some religious services at the congregation along with rabbinic students from Hebrew Union
College. During the presidency of Barbara and Mike, Anshe Emeth supported a youth group that
organized events such as sleepovers and Israeli cultural programs.^[167] Some members of the youth
group came from Springfield and Yellow Springs. In 1982, Anshe Emeth celebrated its first bar
mitzvah in many years when Daniel Feinstein reached the age of 13. Eileen Litchfield is also
among Anshe Emeth’s most active contemporary lay leaders. From 2000 to 2018 she served as
the congregational president. Since 2018 she has been Anshe Emeth’s vice president. She is also
active as a member of the Darke County Foundation Board of Trustees and the Darke County
Historical Society.

As of July 2021, the last bar mitzvah held at Anshe Emeth occurred in 2016, and the last
bas mitzvah in 2018. Five children were included within the congregation in 2015.^[168] In recent
decades Anshe Emeth has also welcomed a number of converts to Judaism. The last conversion
took place in 2016. Members of Anshe Emeth continue to be drawn from a wide area including
Darke, Miami and Shelby counties. Until 2017 the Anshe Emeth Sunday School met twice a
month. From 2010 to 2017 Susan Bargemann assisted Judy in organizing the school. Like Judy,
Susan was a teacher. Activities for Sunday school students included Bible plays, field trips, and a
pen pal program with Hillel Academy, a Jewish school in Dayton. Chabad of Greater Dayton
also partnered with the Anshe Emeth Sunday School on several occasions.^[169] Anshe Emeth
continues several annual congregational traditions. These include a picnic, Purim play and
Hanukkah latke making party. A highlight of the Hanukkah celebrations is the display of
menorahs in the windows of Anshe Emeth. During December Barbara Freed-Bollenbacher also
loans her menorah collection to the Piqua Public Library for display. Anshe Emeth continues to
welcome student rabbis from Hebrew Union College. Among those who have ministered at
Anshe Emeth is Alysa Stanton, who in 2009 became the first African-American female rabbi to
be ordained. Alysa, who worked as a psychotherapist specializing in grief and loss prior to
starting her studies at Hebrew Union College, interned at Anshe Emeth in 2008 and 2009.^[170]

Members of Anshe Emeth in recent years have come together to support the needs of
their historic building, which will mark its centenary in 2023. A 2011 article in The Dayton
Jewish Observer spoke about some of these maintenance concerns, including a leaky roof which
was ultimately repaired at a cost of $16,000.^[171] The Piqua Foundation has also supported Anshe
Emeth through grants. In recent years some non-Jews have begun to participate in Anshe Emeth.
These individuals include Noahides who, while not converts to Judaism, accept many elements
of the Jewish faith. Non-Jews also support the Jewish community of the Upper Miami Valley in
other ways. For example, in 2018 following the Tree of Life synagogue shooting in Pittsburgh
many non-Jews attended a Friday night Shabbat service at Anshe Emeth including the mayor of
Piqua, the minister of Westminster Presbyterian Church, and the Piqua police chief. Anshe
Emeth programs such as “A Taste of Judaism” also engage non-Jews. With its various programs
and members, Anshe Emeth continues to serve as a unique center for Jewish life in the Upper
Miami Valley.

Footnotes

1 “150+ Year History of Anshe Emeth,” Congregation Anshe Emeth, accessed June 18, 2021,
https://ansheemeth.org/about-us-2/history/.
2 Obituary of Moses Friedlich, Piqua Daily Call, August 04, 1892.
3 Ibid.
4 “From Piqua, Ohio,” American Israelite (CincinnatI), May 17, 1878.
5 Obituary of Levi Barnett, Piqua Daily Call, June 27, 1896.
6 “Our History,” Temple Israel, accessed June 06, 2021, http://tidayton.org/about-us/our-history/.
7 Michelle Tedford, “Of Blessed Memory,” Dayton Jewish Observer, May 27, 2011.
8 “B’nai B’rith Degree Team Initiates Piqua Class,” Ohio Jewish Chronicle (Columbus), February 18, 1944.
9 Obituary of Barbara Landaner, Miami Helmet (Piqua), September 01, 1898.
10 “Gone to His Father,” Piqua Daily Call, February 06, 1894.
11 Obituary of Abe Simon, Greenville Daily Advocate, February 07, 1900.
12 “Quickly His Life Went Out,” Piqua Daily Call, August 30, 1905.
13 Yearbook of Immigration Statistics: 2008 (Washington, D.C.: Department of Homeland Security, 2009,
https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/Yearbook_Immigration_Statistics_2008.pdf.
14 “Saloons and Things,” Greenville Daily Advocate, February 28, 1975.
15 Obituary of Simon Bachman, Greenville Journal, April 04, 1907.
16 “Pioneer Lady Called Home,” Greenville Democrat, June 05, 1912.
17 Ibid.
18 “Greenville and Palestine Turnpike 1856,” The Darke County Boy, March 01, 1912.
19 Obituary of Moses Huhn, Democratic Advocate, January 07, 1897.
20 “Piqua, O.” Israelite (Cincinnati), February 05, 1858.
21 “150+ Year History of Anshe Emeth,” Congregation Anshe Emeth, accessed June 18, 2021.
22 “Piqua,” Israelite, March 19, 1858.
23 “Piqua, O.” Israelite, February 05, 1858.
24 “Gone to His Father,” Piqua Daily Call, February 06, 1894.
25 “Editorial Correspondence,” Israelite, July 13, 1860.
26 “Purchase Land for a Jewish Cemetery,” Lima Republican-Gazette, January 18, 1917.
27 “Donations for Morocco,” Israelite, March 09, 1860.
28 “The Collection for Palestine,” Occident (Philadelphia), January 01, 1866.
29 “History,” City of Piqua, accessed June 20, 2021, https://piquaoh.org/location/history/.
30 “23rd Wisconsin Infantry History,” Wisconsin Historical Society, accessed June 20, 2021,
https://content.wisconsinhistory.org/digital/collection/tp/id/36182.
31 “Uncle Mose Flesh Entertains Elks,” Piqua Daily Call, February 28, 1919.
32 “Clever Youngsters at Children’s Home Have Christmas Celebration,” Piqua Daily Call, December 23,
1916.
33 “David Urbansky,” Jewish Cemeteries of Greater Cincinnati, accessed June 20, 2021,
https://www.jcemcin.org/david-urbansky/.
34 “David Urbansky a Brave Soldier in the Fifty Eighth O. V. I.,” Piqua Daily Call, January 23, 1897.
35 “David Urbansky,” Jewish Cemeteries of Greater Cincinnati, accessed June 20, 2021.
36 The History of Miami County, Ohio (Chicago: W.H. Beers & Company, 1880) 445.
37 Paul Reines, “Since 1858, Anshe Emeth Has Been Jews’ Beacon,” Dayton Daily News, July 24, 2000.
38 “New Store! New Goods!,” Greenville Journal, December 03, 1874.
39 Abraham Herzstam, letter to the editor, American Israelite, June 17, 1909.
40 “Then There was Felhelm’s Store,” Greenville Daily Advocate, December 13, 1933.
41 “A Card,” Darke County Democratic Advocate, January 27, 1887.
42 “Another Fine Business Block,” Miami Helmet, March 13, 1890.
43 “The Assigness,” Piqua Daily Call, May 25, 1896.
44 “The Quietest Kind of Time,” Miami Helmet, June 16, 1892.
45 Union of American Hebrew Congregations, Statistics of Jews in the United States (Philadelphia:
Edward Stern & Company, 1880), 31,
https://www.google.com/books/edition/Statistics_of_the_Jews_of_the_United_Sta/AWc-AAAAYAAJ?hl=en
&gbpv=0.
46 “Piqua, Ohio,” American Israelite, February 13, 1902.
47 “Women’s Council,” Piqua Daily Call, November 11, 1901.
48 “Day of Atonement,” Piqua Daily Call, October 10, 1894.
49 “A Social Dance,” Springfield Daily Republic, January 10, 1888.
50 “Delaware, O.” American Israelite, November 07, 1884.
51 “Our History in Springfield,” Temple Shalom, accessed June 21, 2021,
http://www.templesholomoh.com/Sholom_AboutUs.html?.
52 “Corner Stone [sic] Services Held,” Lima Daily News, June 12, 1914.
53 “Henry Flesh Passes From Life; Falls into Dreamless Sleep,” Piqua Daily Call, May 31, 1919.
54 “From Piqua, Ohio,” American Israelite, May 17, 1878.
55 “Rites Conducted for Leo M. Flesh,” Piqua Daily Call, December 15, 1944.
56 “The Atlas Underwear Company,” Computerized Heritage Association, accessed June 23, 2021,
https://thetroyhistoricalsociety.org/Stories/Biograph/biog-ae/0526.htm.
57 “Joel W. Flesh, Vice President of Cron-Kills Co., is Stricken Monday,” Piqua Daily Call, January 05,
1931.
58 “Associated Charities,” Piqua Daily Call, December 03, 1904.
59 “Henry Flesh Passes From Life; Falls into Dreamless Sleep,” Piqua Daily Call, May 31, 1919.
60 Ibid.
61 “Protective Association,” Piqua Daily Call, August 02, 1897.
62 “Leo Louis,” Miami County, Ohio Genealogical Researchers, accessed June 22, 2021,
https://thetroyhistoricalsociety.org/Stories/Biograph/biog-fl/3221.htm.
63 “Meyer Louis, Head of Piqua Paper Box Company Dies,” Piqua Daily Call, August 03, 1944.
64 Ibid.
65 “New Telephone Scheme,” Democratic Advocate, March 15, 1894.
66 “Cornell Re-elected by Ohio Clothiers,” Greenville Daily Advocate, February 03, 1948.
67 “Abraham Kahn,” Computerized Heritage Association, accessed June 23, 2021,
https://thetroyhistoricalsociety.org/Stories/Biograph/biog-fl/3191.htm.
68 “Cleveland,” American Israelite, October 16, 1890.
69 “Mrs. Steinberg Called by Death,” Lima Republican-Gazette, March 23, 1921.
70 Obituary of A. Steinberg, Piqua Daily Call, June 11, 1906.
71 “Day of Atonement,” Piqua Daily Call, September 24, 1898.
72 “Hebrew New Year,” Piqua Daily Call, September 12, 1901.
73 Hebrew Standard (New York City), September 27, 1901, p 6.
74 “Shabuoth [sic],” American Israelite, May 25, 1911.
75 “Bible Study,” Piqua Daily Call, May 05, 1902.
76 “Women’s Department,” B’nai B’rith Messenger (Los Angeles), February 20, 1920.
77 “Some Active American Jewish Women,” Jewish Independent (Cleveland), December 25, 1913.
78 “Piqua Man to Wed Girl in Kentucky,” Piqua Daily Call, February 29, 1916.
79 Goodkind, S. B. Eminent Jews of America (Toledo: The American Hebrew Biographical Company, 1918),
148.
80 Congregation Anshe Emeth, May 01, 2017, Congratulations to the family of Joe Kastner, status update
on Facebook, Facebook, https://www.facebook.com/piquatemple/posts/1288235294625735.
81 “Money is Well Spent,” Piqua Daily Leader Dispatch, September 29, 1910.
82 “Louis Ostertag Dies in Piqua,” Journal Herald (Dayton), June 12, 1954.
83 “Our History,” Clean All Services, accessed June 27, 2021, https://www.cleanall.com/history.
84 “Leo Yassenoff,” Columbus Neighborhoods, accessed June 27, 2021,
https://columbusneighborhoods.org/photograph/leo-yassenoff-1930/.
85 “Former Greenville Merchange is Dead,” Greenville Daily Advocate, February 6, 1962
86 “Trojan Seriously Hurt When Train Strikes His Car,” Piqua Daily Call, July 22, 1940.
87“1913 Flood,” Piqua Public Library, accessed June 27, 2021,
https://www.piqualibrary.org/content/1913-flood.
88 “Activities of the Piqua Sisterhood,” B’nai B’rith Messenger (Los Angeles), July 10, 1914.
89″Rites Conducted for Leo M. Flesh,” Piqua Daily Call, December 15, 1944.
90 “Relief for the Jews of Europe and Palestine,” American Israelite, February 17, 1916.
91 “Kline Funderburg Recovering From Heart Condition,” Piqua Daily Call, December 03, 1940.
92 “Interesting Items,” Jewish Voice (St. Louis), July 08, 1910.
93 “Anshe Emeth,” Ohio Jewish Chronicle (Columbus), April 20, 1923.
94 “1922-Ten Years Ago-1932,” Piqua Daily Call, November 07, 1932.
95 “Piqua is an Inspiration,” Ohio Jewish Chronicle, November 03, 1922.
96 “A Model Small-Town Congregation,” Reform Advocate (Chicago), August 05, 1922.
97 “Women’s Department,” B’nai B’rith Messenger (Los Angeles), February 20, 1920.
98 “Jewish Tabernacle to be Built at Piqua, Ohio,” Ohio Jewish Chronicle, June 09, 1922.
99 “The National Federation of Temple Sisterhoods,” B’nai B’rith Messenger, July 13, 1923.
100 “Piqua, Ohio Sisterhood Working to Erect Temple,” Reform Advocate, October 07, 1922.
101 “The National Federation of Temple Sisterhoods,” B’nai B’rith Messenger, July 13, 1923.
102 “Many Observe Sisterhood Day,” Jewish Review and Observer (Cleveland), September 05, 1924.
103 “Kastner Selected,” Dayton Herald, January 06, 1947.
104 Ibid.
105 “Goodman Reports That Central Ohio Has Gone Way Over the Top,” Ohio Jewish Chronicle, June 04,
1926.
106 “David Hirsch Resigns Position With Bakery,” Piqua Daily Call, January 02, 1934.
107 Linda Brotkin, email to author, August 23, 2021.
108 “New ‘Smart Shop’ to Open Saturday,” Greenville Daily Advocate, September 16, 1937.
109 Linda Brotkin, email to author, August 23, 2021.
110 “Former Greenville Merchant is Dead,” Greenville Daily Advocate, February 06, 1962.
111 Joe Eskenazi, “Junkyard Jews,” Jewish News of Northern California (San Francisco), August 20, 2004.
112 Kenneth Shofstall, “Mickler Building is Gutted by Fire,” Piqua Daily Call, January 23, 1930.
113 Ibid.
114 “Ostertag to Open Brand New Store,” Piqua Daily Call, February 05, 1930.
115 “Suits are Filed Against Piquads,” Piqua Daily Call, September 09, 1935.
116 American Jewish Yearbook Vol. 31, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1930: 228,
http://ajcarchives.org/ajcarchive/DigitalArchive.aspx.
117 American Jewish Yearbook Vol. 42, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1941: 257,
http://ajcarchives.org/ajcarchive/DigitalArchive.aspx.
118 American Jewish World (Minneapolis-St Paul), May 14, 1937, p 2.
119 “Dr. Busler at Jewish Temple,” Piqua Daily Call, April 20, 1939.
120 “Rabbi Tarshish Active,” Ohio Jewish Chronicle (Columbus), June 03, 1932.
121 Clara Ziment, “My Spiritual Journey to Who Am I,” Monmouth Center for World Religions and Ethical
Thought (MCWRET), April 17, 2012,
https://interfaithmonmouthcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/ClaraGee-Stamaty-Ziment-Journey-Fin
al.pdf.
122 “Rabbi Louis Witt to Preach Sermon,” Piqua Daily Call, May 22, 1936.
123 “To Confirm Two,” Piqua Daily Call, May 24, 1941.
124 “B’nai B’rith Degree Team Initiates Piqua Class,” Ohio Jewish Chronicle, February 18, 1944.
125 “Piqua Lodge Proud of Hospital; Aided Arthritis Victim,” Greenville Daily Advocate, June 05, 1951.
126 “Luncheon for Mrs. Movitz and Mrs. Sattinger,” Piqua Daily Call, June 29, 1945.
127 Obituary of Jacob Bettman, Reform Advocate (Chicago), May 10, 1935.
128 “Favorite Stove and Range Company,” Piqua Public Library, accessed July 03, 2021,
https://piqualibrary.org/content/favorite-stove.
129 Ibid.
130 “Bettman-Cahn,” American Israelite, September 12, 1895.
131 “Glanz Furs Opens Dress and Sportswear Department,” Jewish Independent, August 24, 1951.
132 “Mother of Joseph Lee of Covington Succumbs Sunday,” Piqua Daily Caller, February 28, 1944.
133 Mark Berman, letter to the author, August 08, 2021.
134 Ibid.
135 Obituary of Leonard Solomon, Greenville Daily Advocate, July 03, 1959.
136 Ibid.
137 “BAS Story,” Beth Abraham Synagogue, accessed July 03, 2021,
https://www.bethabrahamdayton.org/welcome/bas-story/.
138 “Flesh Memorial Trust Established 28 Years Ago,” Piqua Daily Call, April 18, 1974.
139 “Four Former P.O.W.s Return to Duty,” Piqua Daily Call, July 26, 1945.
140 Arthur Werner, letter to the editor, Piqua Daily Call, April 20, 1945.
141 Piquads Named to National Council,” Piqua Daily Call, December 11, 1942.
142 Obituary of Dina Kastner, Dayton Daily News, May 26, 1990.
143 “Piqua Lions Hear of Experiences in German Prison,” Piqua Daily Call, May 02, 1945.
144 “Beta Sigma Sorority,” Piqua Daily Call, October 29, 1942.
145 American Jewish Yearbook Vol. 61, Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1960: 7,
http://ajcarchives.org/ajcarchive/DigitalArchive.aspx.
146 Obituary of Isaac Harrison, American Israelite, December 18, 1986.
147 “About Us,” Barclay’s Downtown Piqua,” accessed July 03, 2021,
http://barclaysdowntownpiqua.com/about-us/.
148 “Joe Klasman, Retired Call City Editor, Dies Thursday,” Piqua Daily Call, May 28, 1976.
149 “Joe Klasman Knew Mobs as Well as Piqua,” Piqua Daily Call, February 25, 1975.
150 “School Registration,” Greenville Daily Advocate, September 17, 1954.
151 “Rabbi’s Aid Takes Post Here Today,” Journal Herald, September 10, 1955.
152 “Work Starts on Piqua Jewish Temple Unit,” Dayton Daily News, August 16, 1957.
153 “Piqua Temple Addition Will Cost $25,000,” Journal Herald, October 24, 1956.
154 “Piqua’s Jewish Temple to Fete Centennial,” Journal Herald, March 10, 1958.
155 “Funds of Temple Anshe Emeth,” Congregation Anshe Emeth, accessed July 03, 2021,
https://ansheemeth.org/about-us-2/funds/.
156 “Piquad Honored,” Journal Herald (Dayton), March 02, 1961.
157 “Minister Named Troy Man of the Year,” Dayton Daily News, March 15, 1959.
158 “B’nai B’rith Lodge to Install Officers,” Greenville Daily Advocate, May 29, 1954.
159 Eileen Litchfield, email to author, May 11, 2021.
160 “Anshe Emeth Presentation Scheduled,” Piqua Daily Call, November 18, 1976.
161 Paul Reines, “Since 1858, Anshe Emeth Has Been Jews’ Beacon,” Dayton Daily News, July 24, 2000.
162 Eileen Litchfield, email to author, May 11, 2021.
163 Clara Barr, interview by Eileen Litchfield, video, 1997.
164 Barbara Freed-Bollenbacher, interview by author, phone, 2021.
165 Judy Feinstein, interview by author, phone, 2021.
166 Judy Feinstein, interview by author, phone, 2021.
167 Judy Feinstein, interview by author, phone, 2021.
168 Marshall Weiss, “Where are the Jews of Dayton,” Dayton Jewish Observer, June 19, 2015.
169 Judy Feinstein, interview by author, phone, 2021.
170 “Alysa Stanton Ordained as First African-American Female Rabbi,”Jewish Women’s Archive, June 06,
2009, https://jwa.org/thisweek/jun/06/2009/alysa-stanton.
171 Martha Jacobs, “Upkeep a Challenge for Piqua Temple,” Dayton Jewish Observer, June 03, 2011.

Bibliography

Primary Sources
“23rd Wisconsin Infantry History.” Wisconsin Historical Society. accessed June 20, 2021.
https://content.wisconsinhistory.org/digital/collection/tp/id/36182.

Goodkind, S. B. Eminent Jews of America (Toledo: The American Hebrew Biographical
Company. 1918).

Jacobs, Martha. “Upkeep a Challenge for Piqua Temple.” Dayton Jewish Observer. June 03,
2011.

Shofstall, Kenneth. “Mickler Building is Gutted by Fire.” Piqua Daily Call. January 23, 1930.

Union of American Hebrew Congregations. Statistics of Jews in the United States (Philadelphia:
Edward Stern & Company. 1880).
https://www.google.com/books/edition/Statistics_of_the_Jews_of_the_United_Sta/AWc-AAAA
YAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=0.

Tedford, Michelle. “Of Blessed Memory.” Dayton Jewish Observer. May 27, 2011.

Weiss, Marshall. “Where are the Jews of Dayton.” Dayton Jewish Observer. June 19, 2015.

Ziment, Clara. “My Spiritual Journey to Who Am I.” Monmouth Center for World Religions and
Ethical Thought (MCWRET). April 17, 2012.
https://interfaithmonmouthcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/ClaraGee-Stamaty-Ziment-Jo
urney-Final.pdf.

Newspapers Utilized
American Israelite (Cincinnati, OH).
American Jewish World (Minneapolis-St Paul).
B’nai B’rith Messenger (Los Angeles).
Cleveland Jewish News (Cleveland, OH).
Darke County Boy (Greenville, OH).
Darke County Democratic Advocate (Greenville, OH).
Dayton Daily News (Dayton, OH).
Dayton Herald (Dayton, OH).
Dayton Jewish Observer (Dayton, OH).
Democratic Advocate (Greenville, OH).
Greenville Daily Advocate (Greenville, OH).
Greenville Democrat (Greenville, OH).
Greenville Journal (Greenville, OH).
Hebrew Standard (New York City).
Israelite (Cincinnati, OH).
Jewish Independent (Cleveland, OH).
Jewish Review and Observer (Cleveland).
Jewish Voice (St. Louis).
Journal Herald (Dayton, OH).
Lima Daily News (Lima, OH).
Lima Republican-Gazette (Lima, OH).
Miami Helmet (Piqua, OH).
Occident (Philadelphia, PA).
Ohio Jewish Chronicle (Columbus, OH).
Piqua Daily Call (Piqua, OH).
Piqua Daily Caller (Piqua, OH).
Piqua Daily Leader Dispatch (Piqua, OH).
Reform Advocate (Chicago).
Springfield Daily Republic (Springfield, OH).

Secondary Sources
150+ Year History of Anshe Emeth.” Congregation Anshe Emeth. Accessed June 18, 2021.
https://ansheemeth.org/about-us-2/history/.

“1913 Flood.” Piqua Public Library. Accessed June 27, 2021.
https://www.piqualibrary.org/content/1913-flood.

“About Us.” Barclay’s Downtown Piqua.” Accessed July 03, 2021.
http://barclaysdowntownpiqua.com/about-us/.

“Abraham Kahn.” Computerized Heritage Association. Accessed June 23, 2021.
https://thetroyhistoricalsociety.org/Stories/Biograph/biog-fl/3191.htm.

Alysa Stanton Ordained as First African-American Female Rabbi. Jewish Women’s Archive.
June 06, 2009. https://jwa.org/thisweek/jun/06/2009/alysa-stanton.

American Jewish Yearbook Vol. 31. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America. 1930:
http://ajcarchives.org/ajcarchive/DigitalArchive.aspx.

American Jewish Yearbook Vol. 42. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America. 1941:
http://ajcarchives.org/ajcarchive/DigitalArchive.aspx.

American Jewish Yearbook Vol. 61. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America. 1960:
http://ajcarchives.org/ajcarchive/DigitalArchive.aspx.

“BAS Story.” Beth Abraham Synagogue. Accessed July 03, 2021.
https://www.bethabrahamdayton.org/welcome/bas-story/.

“David Urbansky.” Jewish Cemeteries of Greater Cincinnati. Accessed June 20, 2021.
https://www.jcemcin.org/david-urbansky/.

Eskenazi, Joe. “Junkyard Jews.” Jewish News of Northern California (San Francisco). August
20, 2004.

“Favorite Stove and Range Company.” Piqua Public Library. Accessed July 03, 2021.
https://piqualibrary.org/content/favorite-stove.

“Funds of Temple Anshe Emeth,” Congregation Anshe Emeth. Accessed July 03, 2021.
https://ansheemeth.org/about-us-2/funds/.

“History.” City of Piqua. Accessed June 20, 2021. https://piquaoh.org/location/history/.

“Leo Louis.” Miami County, Ohio Genealogical Researchers. Accessed June 22, 2021,
https://thetroyhistoricalsociety.org/Stories/Biograph/biog-fl/3221.htm.

“Our History,” Clean All Services, accessed June 27, 2021, https://www.cleanall.com/history.

“Our History.” Temple Israel. Accessed June 06, 2021. http://tidayton.org/about-us/our-history/.

“Our History in Springfield.” Temple Shalom. Accessed June 21, 2021.
http://www.templesholomoh.com/Sholom_AboutUs.html?.

“The Atlas Underwear Company.” Computerized Heritage Association. Accessed June 23, 2021.
https://thetroyhistoricalsociety.org/Stories/Biograph/biog-ae/0526.htm.

The History of Miami County, Ohio (Chicago: W.H. Beers & Company. 1880).

“Leo Yassenoff.” Columbus Neighborhoods. Accessed June 27, 2021.
https://columbusneighborhoods.org/photograph/leo-yassenoff-1930/.

Yearbook of Immigration Statistics: 2008 (Washington, D.C.: Department of Homeland Security.
2009.
https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/Yearbook_Immigration_Statistics_2008.pdf.